An alien kidnaps five high school students, and tells them that one must be killed. They must decide which of them it will be. The five students are: Ray, a typical jock, Danielle, the hottest girl in school, Jason, a stereotypical geek, Brianna, a devout religious girl, and Cody, a social outcast. Once the alien leaves, the students find that they are in a part of their school which has been cut off from the outside world. When their escapes attempts fail, the students begin trying to decide which of them will die. Being the most faithful, Brianna tries to lead the group. Although none of them are comfortable with the situation, Cody seems to be the biggest stick-in-the-mud.